Best GK in EPL?

출처: http://sport.uk.msn.com/football/premier-leagues-best-keepers#image=1

누가 가장 좋은 키퍼인가라는 것을 통계로 뽑아낸 기사인데요.

제가 아스날팬이라 슈체즈니의 순위가 부당하다 이런 이야기는 아니지만

이런 통계가 과연 골키퍼의 모든 수치를 반영하는가에 대해선 살짝 의문입니다.

그래도 뭐 재미론 볼만합니다. 일단 순위와 스탯입니다.


1. David De Gea

Manchester United
Saves to shot ratio 79.4%
--------------------------
Saves made 50
Saves parried safe 17
Saves parries into danger 5
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 1


2. Joe Hart

Manchester City
Saves to shot ratio 77.4%
--------------------------
Saves made 41
Saves parried safe 12
Saves parries into danger 12
Penalties faced 1
Penalties saved 0


3. Michel Vorm

Swansea City
Saves to shot ratio 76.5%
--------------------------
Saves made 52g
Saves parried safe 17
Saves parries into danger 13
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 1


4. Brad Friedel

Tottenham Hotspur
Saves to shot ratio 76.1%
--------------------------
Saves made 51
Saves parried safe 15
Saves parries into danger 9
Penalties faced 0
Penalties saved 0


5. Tim Krul

Newcastle United
Saves to shot ratio 73.9%
--------------------------
Saves made 34
Saves parried safe 12
Saves parries into danger 7
Penalties faced 4
Penalties saved 0


6. Mark Schwarzer

Fulham
Saves to shot ratio 72.9%
--------------------------
Saves made 43
Saves parried safe 7
Saves parries into danger 5
Penalties faced 0
Penalties saved 0


7. Jose Reina

Liverpool
Saves to shot ratio 72.1%
--------------------------
Saves made 31
Saves parried safe 7
Saves parries into danger 7
Penalties faced 1
Penalties saved 0


8. Shay Given

Aston Villa
Saves to shot ratio 71.2%
--------------------------
Saves made 42
Saves parried safe 8
Saves parries into danger 16
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 0


9. Wayne Hennessey

Wolverhampton Wanderers
Saves to shot ratio 70.5%
--------------------------
Saves made 55
Saves parried safe 13
Saves parries into danger 12
Penalties faced 3
Penalties saved 2


10. Simon Mignolet

Sunderland
Saves to shot ratio 70.3%
--------------------------
Saves made 26
Saves parried safe 8
Saves parries into danger 5
Penalties faced 1
Penalties saved 0


11. John Ruddy

Norwich City
Saves to shot ratio 70%
--------------------------
Saves made 42
Saves parried safe 9
Saves parries into danger 6
Penalties faced 3
Penalties saved 1


12. Ben Foster

West Bromwich Albion
Saves to shot ratio 67.2%
--------------------------
Saves made 41
Saves parried safe 14
Saves parries into danger 5
Penalties faced 5
Penalties saved 1


13. Ali Al-Habsi

Wigan Athletic
Saves to shot ratio 67.1%
--------------------------
Saves made 49
Saves parried safe 22
Saves parries into danger 12
Penalties faced 3
Penalties saved 2


14. Tim Howard

Everton
Saves to shot ratio 65.2%
--------------------------
Saves made 30
Saves parried safe 9
Saves parries into danger 6
Penalties faced 4
Penalties saved 2


15. Asmir Begovic

Stoke City
Saves to shot ratio 62.8%
--------------------------
Saves made 32
Saves parried safe 11
Saves parries into danger 4
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 0


16. Jussi Jaaskelainen

Bolton Wanderers
Saves to shot ratio 62.3%
--------------------------
Saves made 43
Saves parried safe 14
Saves parries into danger 6
Penalties faced 1
Penalties saved 0


17. Paddy Kenny

QPR
Saves to shot ratio 60%
--------------------------
Saves made 33
Saves parried safe 10
Saves parries into danger 7
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 0


18. Wojciech Szczesny

Arsenal
Saves to shot ratio 57.4%
--------------------------
Saves made 31
Saves parried safe 14
Saves parries into danger 2
Penalties faced 1
Penalties saved 0


19. Petr Cech

Chelsea
Saves to shot ratio 55.8%
--------------------------
Saves made 19
Saves parried safe 6
Saves parries into danger 5
Penalties faced 2
Penalties saved 0


20. Paul Robinson

Blackburn Rovers
Saves to shot ratio 52.4%
--------------------------
Saves made 33
Saves parried safe 17
Saves parries into danger 1
Penalties faced 3
Penalties saved 1





-이 통계에 대해서 트위터의 @ArsenalColumn 씨는 이러한 의견을 내놓았습니다.


This is a flawed analysis on who, statistically, are the League's best keepers. Saves to shots is an imperfect measure:

For example, Wojciech Szczesny doesn't face nearly as much shots as other 'keepers and often, the chances he faces are of higher quality.

Arsenal's style means the chances that are conceded are against a less organised defence with more space to attack.




 간단히 번역해보자면 StS (save to Shot) Ratio는 불완전한 수치라는건데요. 아스날의 예를 들면 아스날의
플레이스타일상 키퍼는 조금더 심각한 위기상황을 맞딱뜨린다는 견해입니다. 그리고 아스날이 찬스를 주는 상황은 수비가 덜 정비된 상황이거나 공격할 공간이 많이 허용된 상황이라는거네요. 즉 4백을 높은 라인으로 유지하는 상황에서 역습을 맞는 상황들이 아스날의 실점의 많은 부분을 차지하기때문이라고 이해하면 될꺼같아요. 사실 이 통계에서도 눈에 띄는거지만 첼시의 체흐의 경우도 같습니다. 첼시 역시 AVB의 전술이 4백을 위로 올리기에 그가 맞는 세이브상황은 비교적 실점율이 높은 찬스가 될 가능성이 크기 때문이죠.
 
그렇다고 해서 위의 통계가 완전히 형편없다라는 이야긴 아닙니다. 슈체즈니의 경우 중거리슛이나 프리킥같은 상황에서 작년에 비해 파포스트의 반응이 비교적 느린 점이 눈에 띈다거나 체흐의 경우에도 예전같은 모습을 보이지 못하거나하는 게 확실히 눈에 보이긴 하니까요. 또 한편으로  어느정도 각팀의 문제를 엿볼수 있다거나 -폴로빈슨의 스탯과 현재 블랙번의 실점율과의 관계- 반대로 현재 가장 최저 실점을 다투는 세팀 맨시,맨유,리버풀같은 경우에 골키퍼 역시 상위권의 스탯을 보여준다라는 것도 하나의 흥미있는 부분이 아닌가 생각해 봅니다.